Three stars. Rated PG-13, and somewhat generously, for brief sensuality and relentless, soul-crushing violence
By Derrick Bang • Originally published in The Davis Enterprise, 3.25.16
A perceptive philosophical theme
serves as this film’s beating heart, a tenet that — quite sadly — reflects these
cynical and despondent times: that, just as we worship our heroes, we’re all
too eager to tear them down.
Because we’re also jealous, and
more than a little fearful. Because such individuals are different than you and
I.
The “Big Blue” standing as the
moral centerpiece of Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice couldn’t be more
different than the cheerful, easily admired boy scout played by Christopher
Reeve in his quartet of films, several decades and a tidal shift of public
sentiment ago. This 21st century Superman exists in a mutinous, resentful
America that mirrors our own today, with a populous eager to be suspicious of
any “alien” floating amongst us.
The resulting film is grim, its
tone unrelentingly melancholy, its subtext downright depressing: We clearly don’t
deserve a Superman.
For longtime comic book fans, the
irony is palpable. Back in the early 1960s, DC Comics’ stable of heroes —
Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman et al — were colorful but simplistic champions
who routinely, almost casually, defeated equally flamboyant villains in
self-contained storylines that mirrored popular TV dramas that did the same:
all problems solved in one quick read (or one quick hour), and then on to the
next adventure, perhaps with a quip or two. Nobody ever changed, because nobody
had anything approaching an actual personality.
Upstart Marvel Comics upended
this one-dimensional formula with its eye-opening roster of angst-laden
superheroes. When out of their costumes, Spiderman, Iron Man, the Fantastic
Four and their brethren felt like the folks next door, complete with anxieties
and ground-level responsibilities. Their clashes with bad guys often occurred
over multiple-issue story arcs: the outcomes less definitive, and often tinged
with regret.
How interesting, then, that these
two companies have switched roles en route to big-screen domination. Even at
their most dire, Marvel movies are fun, their cataclysmic events leavened with
an engaging layer of droll humor: a wink and nudge established the first time
Robert Downey Jr. donned his Iron Man togs.