Five stars. Rated R, for nudity, strong sexual content, profanity and violence
By Derrick Bang • Originally published in The Davis Enterprise, 12.29.17
Truly adult fairy tales may be
the rarest of movie treasures, given how almost everything these days —
particularly what emanates from corporate Hollywood — is designed for all-ages
audiences.
We need look elsewhere for
thoughtful, intelligent and provocative alternative fare: the cinematic equivalent
of, say, Neil Gaiman’s The Ocean at the
End of the Lane (far more disturbingly
graphic — but just as imaginative — as his Coraline
or The Graveyard Book).
France’s Marc Caro comes to mind,
with Delicatessen and The City of Lost Children, the latter
co-directed with Jean-Pierre Jeunet, equally adept at the genre, as evidenced
by Amélie and Micmacs. Spain’s Alejandro Amenábar gave us The Others.
But they all pale alongside
Mexico’s Guillermo del Toro, whose intriguing early efforts in this rarefied
environment — Mimic and The Devil’s Backbone — were but a
prelude to the masterful Pan’s Labyrinth:
by far one of the most unsettling and provocative blends of fantasy and
real-world horror ever brought to the big screen.
Until now.
The Shape of Water is an entirely different sort of
Del Toro masterpiece: a richly detailed parable of lonely people coping with
extraordinary circumstances, while confronting the monsters in our midst. The
narrative — co-written by Del Toro and Vanessa Taylor — has the lyrical quality
of a gently poignant fable, which nonetheless conceals the sort of savagely
ironic message beloved by Rod Serling.
It feels like one thing, upon
entry: becomes something entirely different, before we’re allowed to exit.
Best of all, the film is powered
by a truly stunning starring performance by Sally Hawkins, who in a few short
years has emerged as one of the world’s finest and most sensitively nuanced
actresses. She has enjoyed a remarkable year: This film follows her delicately
crafted work in summer’s Maudie, and
her unforgettable portrayal of Nova Scotia folk artist Maud Lewis.
Nobody could have expected a
second, equally transcendent performance in the same year. Her character here
is similarly disenfranchised, and yet entirely different: a lonely, quietly
withdrawn woman who blossoms — like a flower unveiling luminescent colors in
bright sunlight — under highly
unusual conditions.
The setting is Baltimore; the
time is the early 1960s. On the one hand, this is recognizably our reality, as
evidenced by familiar clothes, cars and (frequently intolerant) attitudes. People
amuse themselves, at home after work, with soporific sitcoms such as Mr. Ed and The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis. Lurid news reports are a daily
reminder of post-atomic Cold War paranoia.
And yet other aspects quickly
signal that this isn’t quite our world,
but in fact a closely related parallel reality.