Friday, November 20, 2026

I Play Rocky: A total knockout!

I Play Rocky (2026) • View trailer
Five stars (out of five); rated PG-13, for fleeting profanity and brief sexual content
Available via: Movie theaters
By Derrick Bang • Published in The Davis Enterprise, 11.22.26

Stories like this are the reason starry-eyed hopefuls seek fame and fortune in the film and music industries.

 

Because you just never know...

 

During — and despite — a mountain of career setbacks, Sylvester Stallone (Anthony
Ippolito) has a couple of true believers in his corner: none more affectionate than his
loyal bullmastiff, Butkus.

Exactly half a century later, I still vividly remember the tagline for 1976’s Rocky: “His whole life was a million-to-one shot.”

Ironically — as this fact-based drama depicts — that statement is even more jaw-droppingly apt with respect to what Sylvester Stallone went through, in order to get that film made.

 

On top of which, director Peter Farrelly and scripter Peter Gamble have delivered a poignant docudrama with all the heart, inspiration and fist-pumping exhilaration that made people stand up and cheer, back in 1976.

 

I fully expect this film to prompt the same reaction.

 

In addition to the sensational script and sensitive direction, Farrelly and casting director Rick Montgomery worked a miracle with star Anthony Ippolito, who isn’t merely the spitting image of a young Stallone; he’s also note-perfect with respect to posture, expressions, line deliveries and Sly’s distinctive, marbles-in-the-mouth manner of speaking. Seriously, the impersonation is downright spooky.

 

(It’s amusing to note that Ippolito played Al Pacino in TV’s 2022 miniseries, The Offer.)

 

Nor is Ippolito the only one. AnnaSophia Robb is equally spot-on as Sasha Czack, who becomes Sly’s first wife; Kiki Seto eerily evokes young Talia Shire; Scot Teller similarly channels Burt Young; and Stephan James is hilariously reminiscent of the young Carl Weathers. Robert Morgan, who appears briefly as Burgess Meredith, is the only one who doesn’t quite evoke the real deal.

 

But those Rocky co-stars don’t enter this story until late in the second act.

 

Farrelly and Gamble introduce “Mike” Stallone in his mid-20s, in the early 1970s. He’s living hand-to-mouth in New York City, doing his best to kick-start an acting career which thus far has delivered only a handful of uncredited appearances as an extra. He keeps losing menial jobs by ducking out for casting calls.

 

At night, with nothing else to do, Stallone reads. He also writes spec movie scripts.

 

Unable to make rent in his fleabag apartment at one point, he winds up sleeping on the street, where he encounters and abandoned bullmastiff puppy he names Butkus, after Pro Football Hall of Famer Dick Butkus.

 

During his next short-lived job, as a movie theater ticket-taker, he’s attracted to the young woman selling the tickets; she turns out to be Sasha. Their meet-cute moment starts shakily, but she’s quickly won over by his self-deprecating charisma. The city is a dangerous place to be walking home alone, he insists; so what, she archly responds, you’ll protect me?

 

“No,” he replies, “I was hoping you’d protect me.”

 

The scene is beyond charming, and merely the first of this film’s many marvelous moments. Ippolito also deftly conveys the most fascinating aspect of Stallone’s personality: Despite having genuinely low self-esteem — the result of growing up with a father (Matt Dillon, teeth-grindingly unpleasant) who puts him down at every opportunity — Stallone is very sure of himself, and his potential.

 

And when the latter is dismissed by others, he can be astonishingly stubborn.

 

Mike and Sasha marry in short order; she insists that he go by his given name, Sylvester, “because the world is full of Mikes.” He continues to write scripts, very slowly, with block printing; she laboriously retypes them, hunting and pecking on what looks like a small Smith-Corona. (Greater love hath no woman.)

 

The next failed casting call introduces him to co-producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), not quite a decade into their impressive collaborative career, which began with 1967’s Point Blank and subsequently included 1969’s They Shoot Horses, Don’t They? and 1972’s The New Centurions.

 

Byrne and Kebbell play off each other with an effortless blend of warmth, compassion, emotional heft and mild comic timing. The actual Winkler and Chartoff couldn’t have asked for better portrayals.

 

Stallone impulsively slips one of his scripts into their “To be read” pile. 

 

When they call him back, a few days later, Stallone assumes it’s for an acting role. But no; they’re impressed by his writing, and want to read more. Stallone complies, but they still don’t see the passion that makes a script memorable. (In a droll touch, two of these “spec script” concepts ultimately became Stallone projects, after his career took off.)

 

Brooding, nursing a beer in a local bar, Stallone and the other patrons watch, astonished, as the Muhammad Ali/Chuck Wepner fight plays out on television.

 

Stallone returns home, and writes Rocky during a nonstop three days. Winkler and Chartoff offer to buy it on the spot, immediately blue-skying bankable movie star names. Stallone interrupts: No, he insists, you don’t get it. I want to play Rocky.

 

This, from somebody who — at this point — has only one reasonable supporting role in his pocket, in 1974’s The Lords of Flatbush.

 

Even so, Stallone won’t budge.

 

Winkler and Chartoff gamely take the project to studio exec Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts, condescending to the point of being nasty), this story’s sole fictitious key character. (Gamble made him a composite of several 1970s-era studio chiefs, and this script’s closest thing to a villain.) They finagle a $4 million budget ... until Maddox hears that a total unknown demands to play the starring role.

 

“Offer him $25,000,” Maddox scoffs. “He’ll go away.”

 

Stallone doesn’t budge.

 

That’s all you’ll get out of me, because from this point forward, the story slides into an astonishing degree of Truth Is Stranger Than Fiction. (Seriously, it’s unbelievable.)

 

Jay Duplass eventually pops up as then-fledgling movie director John G. Avildsen, who had a reputation for shooting quickly and economically. Duplass is a hoot, acknowledging from the start that he can be impatient ... but he also lives, breathes and understands what makes movies tick.

 

Michael Fuchs has a telling supporting role as Garret Brown, who won a 1978 Academy Award of Merit for a reason that will not be divulged here. But it’s important to note that Brown’s introduction to these characters unfolds in a manner that also is 100 percent accurate to what actually happened. Gamble shaped his script from a half-century’s worth of Stallone’s interviews, along with his autobiographical Official Rocky Scrapbook.

 

And, yes; at just the right moment, composer Dave Palmer’s uplifting score yields to Bill Conti’s iconic main theme to the 1976 film. How could Farrelly do otherwise?


In every respect, this film is guaranteed to be a knockout crowd pleaser. 

No comments: