Two stars. Rated R, for profanity, dramatic intensity, strong violence and gore
By Derrick Bang
If director Eli Roth is hoping
for mainstream respectability, this isn’t the right path.
The original Charles Bronson Death Wish was a cultural flashpoint
back in 1974 (its four progressively tawdry sequels, not so much). The
political divide was incendiary, with mounting raucous protests ultimately
helping to force a corrupt president from office; big-city crime and street
violence were out of control; the older generation was dismayed by a younger
generation that seemed not to care about much of anything.
Half the country viewed Bronson’s
film as a fascist nightmare; the other half thought his character’s actions
fell under the heading of Damn Well About Time.
Things change ... not so much.
There’s no question that Roth and
scripter Joe Carnahan’s updated remake is well-timed, but — sadly — reaction to
this film is likely to be even more polarized. Half the audience will regard it
as an irresponsible NRA recruitment tool; the other half, once again, will
smile in satisfaction and think, Hey, that’s a good way to solve some problems.
The third half, based on
Wednesday evening’s preview screening, will chortle gleefully each time Bruce
Willis dispatches a baddie. And that’s perhaps even more disturbing.
Granted, this updated Death Wish has some mild laugh lines;
most, however, derive from the verbal skirmishes between Paul Kersey (Willis)
and investigating detectives Kevin Raines (Dean Norris) and Leonore Jackson
(Kimberly Elise).
I fail to see how watching some
guy’s eyes pop out of his graphically crushed head warrants a chuckle, let
alone rip-snortin’ peals of laughter. But that’s to be expected from Roth’s
core fan base, which — let us recall — laps up the torture-porn trash for which
he is best known: Cabin Fever, The Green Inferno, the Hostel series and others I’ve blissfully
forgotten.
Roth may have attracted a solid
cast for this outing, and the film may benefit from whatever name-brand
recognition its predecessor still delivers ... but as the (original) saying
goes, a hog in a silk waistcoat is still a hog.
The core story hasn’t changed
much. Dedicated Chicago surgeon Paul Kersey has it all: a hospital practice at
which he excels; a loving wife (Elisabeth Shue, as Lucy); a devoted daughter
(Camila Morrone, as Jordan), who just got into the college of her choice; and a
gorgeous home in an upscale neighborhood.
No sign of a dog. Seems like they
should have a dog.
The film’s opening montage
eavesdrops on police band frequencies, radio talk shows and social media
exchanges obsessed with the same thing: shooting statistics — injuries and
homicides — that are salaciously exaggerated for the purposes of this
storyline. Indeed, social media’s ability to fan the flames is one of the
culture shifts acknowledged by Carnahan’s script, but he does little beyond
exploiting it.
What soon happens to Kersey’s
family also results from technological “progress,” and it’s a sharply effective
reminder that the “interconnectedness of all things” can be a very, very bad idea.
In the aftermath, a
grief-stricken Kersey is left numb: unable to get through each day, uncertain
what to do next. His brother Frank (Vincent D’Onofrio), something of a
financial mooch, isn’t much help; father-in-law Ben (Len Cariou) pops up just
long enough to mutter angrily about a man’s need to defend his castle.
Kersey does all the right things
during his early interactions with Raines and Jackson, but he can see they’re
overwhelmed. Flickering alternative thoughts — and a hilariously overblown TV
ad (which, sadly, probably isn’t unrealistic) — lead him to a local Guns R Us,
but he clocks the ubiquitous security cameras and opts out.
A weapon of choice falls into his
hands through sheer caprice, and he takes advantage. Unable to do anything
about his own family, Kersey embarks on a late-night campaign of random social
justice. Once again due to social media, his activities don’t go unnoticed,
although the protective hoodies conceal his identity.
And so the anonymous slayings of
criminals grabs everybody’s attention, and radio pundits debate whether this
mysterious avenger is a guardian angel or a grim reaper.
It’s a valid debate — and quite
timely, at the moment — but no more than white noise in this film. Roth and
Carnahan couldn’t care less about the gun argument; they’re focused solely on
increasingly vicarious mayhem.
That’s the key difference between
this film and its 1974 predecessor. Love him or hate him, Bronson’s Kersey was
never more than an average citizen who wielded a gun with escalating skill and
anger. Willis’ Kersey, although initially cut from the same uncertain and
unpracticed cloth, rapidly morphs into a superhero who — during one notorious
sequence — sets up a death trap that’d be more at home in the Saw franchise. With similar results.
Roth just can’t help reverting to
his gleefully gruesome, splatter-happy self.
Willis swans through most of the
film with an immovable stone face that makes Bronson look like Olivier.
Granted, Willis’ Kersey is supposed to be tamped down by grief, but his
somnambulance more frequently seems the result of too many Quaaludes.
He therefore becomes the least
interesting character in his own film. Norris’ Detective Raines has buckets more
personality, and has a lot of fun with a running gag involving his need to lose
weight. D’Onofrio’s Frank is intriguing for the questions that flutter in his
orbit; there’s something about the guy that always seems a bit ... off.
Morrone is adorably bubbly as
Jordan, and Shue makes Lucy the world’s best wife and mother. Indeed, the two
actress’ early scenes with Willis make him
look better than he deserves.
Heck, even Beau Knapp — as the
primary baddie, Knox — better utilizes his screen time. Knapp looks
impressively sinister to begin with, and his performance here is chilling.
Ludwig Göransson’s so-called
score is unremarkable, and most frequently drowned out by a barrage of
offensively profane shock rap.
All told, this Death Wish is about what can be expected
from a low-rent exploitation flick. It’s sad to see the likes of Willis
headlining such disposable junk ... but, then, he doesn’t bring much to the
party either.
No comments:
Post a Comment