Three stars. Rated PG, for no particular reason
By Derrick Bang
In theory, a 94-minute animated
feature paced with the manic intensity of a 7-minute Warner Bros. cartoon
must’ve seemed like a great idea.
In practice ... not so much.
![]() |
| The gang's all here: clockwise from left, Julian, Peaches, Ellie, Manny, Shira, Diego, Granny, Sid, Crash and Eddie. As for what they're all staring at ... well, that would be giving away too much! |
This fifth (!) entry in the
popular Ice Age series is relentless:
a never-ending succession of hyper-paced slapstick, sight gags and one-liners,
all of which overwhelm the gentle family-unity message that struggles to be
heard amid the chaos. Watching this film rapidly becomes an endurance test,
after which one is utterly overwhelmed and exhausted.
Additionally, the four credited
writers — Aubrey Solomon, Michael J. Wilson, Michael Berg and Yoni Brenner —
have augmented the already enormous ensemble cast with a wealth of new
characters. The result is total overload, to the detriment of several regular
players, most notably Diego, the sabertooth voiced by Denis Leary. He
contributes absolutely nothing to the narrative, and his recently acquired gal
pal Shira (Jennifer Lopez) fares even worse.
It’s all too much. As the third
act introduced yet another set of blissed-out newcomers, shepherded by the
fortune cookie-tongued Shangri Llama (Jesse Tyler Ferguson), Constant Companion
and I glanced at each other and mouthed, Seriously?
If all concerned — co-directors
Galen T. Chu and Mike Thurmeier, and the aforementioned writers — are looking
to kill this once-charming franchise, I can think of no better way. The
tenderness and wit have been lost.
Everybody involved with 2002’s
original Ice Age understood the
importance of balance. The bulk of the story was fairly serious — disparate
prehistoric creatures banding together for the common good — with the
occasional silly one-liners limited to the slovenly Sid, the sloth (John
Leguizamo). Machine-gun slapstick was the sole province of the frantic, twitchy
Scrat, whose rodent quest for precious acorns served as brief madcap “bumpers”
between the core story’s various acts.
This fifth entry is nothing but madcap bumpers. It’s soulless.


